Knowledge · Ira Berg, 7 November 2026
Does ChatGPT make you dumb? What research really says
In short: No, ChatGPT does not automatically make you dumb. But studies show that people who regularly hand their thinking over to AI think less critically and remember less. People who use AI as a conversation partner and keep thinking hardly show these downsides.
Where the worry comes from
In summer 2025 a study from the MIT Media Lab went around the world, with headlines like “ChatGPT makes your brain lazy”. The researchers had 54 people write essays, some with ChatGPT, some with a search engine and some with no tools at all, while measuring brain activity with EEG.
The ChatGPT group showed the weakest brain connectivity. These participants also remembered their own texts less well and felt less ownership of them. The authors call this an accumulating “cognitive debt”.
What the study does not show
Impressive as it sounds, the study did not prove that ChatGPT makes you permanently less intelligent. The sample was small, the task very specific, and at the time of the coverage the paper had not yet been peer reviewed. The researchers themselves warned against exaggerated conclusions.
What remains is a serious hint: when an AI does the thinking, our brain works less. It is a bit like satnav. If you only ever follow the voice, at some point you no longer know your way around your own town.
Other studies point the same way
A survey of 319 knowledge workers by Microsoft Research and Carnegie Mellon University (CHI 2025) found that the more people trust AI, the less critically they think about its answers. People who trust their own skills check more carefully.
A study by Michael Gerlich with 666 participants (Societies 2025) found a link between frequent AI use and lower critical thinking, explained by so called cognitive offloading. Younger people were more affected. Note that this is a correlation, not proof of cause and effect.
The good news
The same research also shows how to do better. In an experiment with nearly 1,000 high school students, the negative effects largely disappeared when the AI gave hints instead of finished answers (PNAS 2025). What matters is how you use it.
If you read, ask, push back and add your own ideas, the AI is your training partner. If you only type “ok, go on”, it does the training for you. All studies at a glance
How to check yourself
Honestly, you hardly notice how often you just wave answers through. That is why we built Monkey Score. The extension shows how much you think for yourself when working with ChatGPT, Gemini and Claude. Everything is analysed on your device and nothing is sent.
FAQ
Does ChatGPT make you dumb?
Not automatically. But studies show that the brain works less and you remember less when AI does the thinking. People who actively think along, ask and check hardly show these downsides.
What did the MIT study on ChatGPT show?
In a small EEG study with 54 people, the group writing essays with ChatGPT showed the weakest brain connectivity and remembered their own texts less well. The study was small and initially not peer reviewed, so it does not prove lasting harm.